Death by a thousand planning applications

How Much More of the Lagan Valley Are We Prepared to Lose?

Another green field in the Lagan Valley Regional Park, an Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty, is being eyed for development. This time, the proposal is for a holiday park at Ballyskeagh Road, Drumbeg. Seventeen substantial accommodation buildings, some nine metres high, eleven camping pitches, four outdoor padel courts and the infrastructure to support them. All on land that is not zoned for development.

There is something increasingly absurd about the way we treat our protected landscapes. We celebrate their beauty, promote their wildlife, congratulate ourselves on their special status and then entertain proposals to build over the very things that make them worth protecting.

The Lagan Valley is Northern Ireland’s first and only Regional Park. Its fields, hedgerows, mature trees and waterways form a living landscape between Belfast and Lisburn, providing habitat for wildlife and a place of respite for the communities around it. Yet to a developer, another green field appears to represent another opportunity.

The Ballyskeagh proposal is not an isolated incident. Across the Lagan Valley, development pressure continues to advance, field by field, application by application. Each scheme arrives with its own carefully drawn boundary, as though the land beyond it exists in some separate universe. But nature does not work like that. Bats follow hedgerows, birds move between feeding grounds, insects depend on connected habitats, and water travels wherever gravity takes it. Damage one part of that system and the consequences do not necessarily stop at the red line on a planning drawing.

Protected, until someone wants to build on it

The Ballyskeagh site is not zoned for development. That does not automatically prohibit every form of construction, but it ought to prompt a fundamental question: why should a substantial commercial complex be considered appropriate here?

We are told these are holiday accommodation buildings rather than houses. At the public consultation, a representative reportedly explained that they would not be permanent residences and could only be occupied for ten months of the year. But a building does not become less intrusive because its occupants must leave for two months. Nine metres is still nine metres. Roads, lighting, drainage and wastewater requirements do not disappear when the accommodation is described as tourism.

Nor does the promise of economic activity automatically establish a public benefit. Tourism can create jobs and support businesses, but where is the convincing evidence that this development would improve the Regional Park, restore habitats or benefit the people who already live beside it? What would be gained that could not be achieved in a less environmentally sensitive location?

The developers are entitled to submit proposals, but they should have to demonstrate why this particular site is appropriate. The description of a development should not become a means of avoiding proper scrutiny of its physical and environmental consequences.

We are running out of excuses

Northern Ireland’s biodiversity crisis is well documented. Our wildlife has suffered decades of habitat loss, pollution, agricultural intensification and fragmentation. Yet we continue to behave as though another field, another hedgerow or another patch of undisturbed ground is a negligible sacrifice.

It is easy to overlook the ecological importance of ordinary countryside. A field does not need to contain an exceptionally rare species to have value. Its margins may feed pollinators, its hedges may guide bats through the darkness, and its soil may sustain countless organisms we seldom see. These are not decorative extras. They are the workings of a living ecosystem.

Developers may offer new planting, landscaping and mitigation. Some measures can reduce harm, but we should be wary of the suggestion that mature habitats can simply be replaced. A newly planted hedge is not a 150-year-old hedge. A landscaped strip between buildings is not an undisturbed field. And a promise to improve biodiversity elsewhere does not necessarily compensate for what is lost here.

The first question should surely be whether the damage needs to happen at all.

The community is part of this landscape too

The people living around Ballyskeagh and the Hermitage are entitled to ask what this proposal would mean for their homes and surroundings. There are legitimate concerns about traffic, flooding, drainage, wastewater capacity, lighting and noise, particularly from the proposed outdoor padel courts.

These are not the complaints of people who believe the countryside should never change. They are questions about whether a protected landscape and an established community should bear the environmental and practical costs of a commercial venture whose wider benefits have yet to be convincingly demonstrated.

Quarterlands Group has spent years examining planning applications, ecological reports, pollution incidents and wastewater infrastructure across this area. Again and again, local residents find themselves having to explain why a protected landscape deserves protection. They give up their evenings, study technical documents and challenge assumptions that should have been questioned long before a proposal reached the public.

Something is badly wrong when the people defending the countryside must work harder to justify its survival than those seeking to develop it.

Death by a thousand planning applications

Perhaps the greatest danger is not any single development but the cumulative effect of them all. One field becomes a holiday park. Another becomes housing. A hedgerow disappears here, a quiet corner is illuminated there. Each change is considered individually, each loss presented as manageable, until the landscape we claimed to value has been altered beyond recognition.

We speak endlessly about biodiversity recovery, climate resilience and protecting the natural environment. But these commitments mean very little if they evaporate whenever an undeveloped site attracts commercial interest.

The Ballyskeagh Holiday Park remains a proposal, and its impacts must be properly assessed before any planning decision is made. Yet the wider issue is already plain. We cannot continue to treat the Lagan Valley as both a protected landscape and a reserve of land waiting to be commercially exploited.

Its fields are not empty spaces. Its hedgerows are not inconveniences. Its wildlife is not an obstacle to be managed out of the way.

The Lagan Valley Regional Park is valuable because of what it already is. We should not have to wait until we have lost it to understand that.